Delaying COVID-19 emergency measures linked to higher mortality in US
Written by James Kingsland on July 20, 2020 — Fact checked by Zia Sherrell, MPH
At the start of the COVID-19 outbreak, each additional day that states delayed declaring an emergency was associated with a 5% increase in mortality, a study has found.
Share on PinterestNew research shows that COVID-19 mortality risk rose with each day that officials did not implement emergency measures.
Image credit: Joe Raedle/Getty Images.
The imposition of physical distancing measures by state governments during the COVID-19 pandemic has been politically controversial in the United States.
Critics have questioned the necessity and effectiveness of such measures, particularly in light of the considerable economic costs.
In the absence of direct evidence early in the outbreak, as the number of local cases mounted, states based their decisions to close schools and declare an emergency on modeling studies and evidence from past epidemics.
Stay informed with live updates on the current COVID-19 outbreak and visit our coronavirus hub for more advice on prevention and treatment.
A 2007 analysis of the influenza pandemic of 1918–1919, for example, found that earlier closure of schools and bans on public gatherings by U.S. city authorities was associated with lower subsequent mortality in those cities.
Researchers in Philadelphia, PA, have now published one of the first studies specifically assessing the effect of physical distancing on COVID-19 death rates.
They used the unambiguous dates when states declared emergencies and closed schools as proxies for when each began to implement significant physical distancing measures.
“Before this study, we assumed social distancing worked based on modeling and studies of prior pandemics, but we didn’t have substantial quantitative data to show its effectiveness for COVID-19,” says lead author Nadir Yehya, assistant professor in the Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia and the University of Pennsylvania.
“Our analyses demonstrate that states that issued emergency declarations earlier helped curb the spread of the disease,” he says. “These results confirm how important it is to implement social distancing measures early to reduce COVID-19 deaths.”
The study appears in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases.
A 28-day window
To test whether there was an association between physical distancing measures and mortality, the researchers analyzed 55,146 confirmed COVID-19 deaths across 37 states between January 21, 2020, and April 29, 2020.
They assigned the day when a state exceeded 10 COVID-19 deaths as “day one” and noted the number of deaths after 28 days.
After making adjustments for demographic variables, such as population size, density, and age distribution, every day that states delayed declaring an emergency was associated with a 5% increase in mortality.
Each day’s delay in closing schools was associated with a 6% increase in mortality.
By redefining the first confirmed death in a state as day one, the researchers were able to obtain 28-day mortality data for all 50 states.
The results were very similar across the states. In fact, all the associations held up after excluding the states of New York and New Jersey — which had exceptionally high death rates early on in the pandemic — from the analyses.