Rise in negative health behaviors during lockdown connected to poor mental health in Scotland
Reviewed by Emily Henderson, B.Sc.Nov 4 2020
A rise in negative health behaviors – such as lack of sleep, exercise and an unhealthy diet – is connected to poorer mental health during the tightest restrictions of Scotland's COVID-19 lockdown, a new study has confirmed.
Research conducted on 20 May 2020 and led by University of the West of Scotland (UWS), in partnership with Glasgow Caledonian University (GCU), has concluded that these changes contributed to a higher negative mood and that maintaining, or even improving, health behaviours in a lockdown situation is key to sustaining positive mental health.
The study, funded by the Chief Scientist Office (CSO), also found a link between increased alcohol consumption when living with children, and a poorer diet if the person's working status had been affected by COVID-19.
When the Scottish Government instigated the initial societal lockdown in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, many subsequently experienced significant lifestyle changes, alongside the stresses of potentially catching the virus or experiencing bereavement."
Dr Joanne Ingram, Lecturer, School of Education and Social Sciences, University of the West of Scotland
"We know that stressful situations and poorer health behaviours, such as higher alcohol consumption, unhealthy diet, poorer sleep quality and physical inactivity are frequently linked to poor mental health; however, our objective was to examine changes in health behaviours and their relationship with negative mood during the COVID-19 lockdown."
The study found that:
- Increased alcohol consumption was linked to living with children, but not to negative mood.
- Poorer diet was linked to more-negative mood, and to changes to working status. Those who had changed their work status due to the COVID-19 pandemic reported that their diet had become unhealthier.
- Poorer sleep quality was linked with more-negative mood, and with 'shielding' from the virus. Shielding was the only COVID-19-related factor which was associated with changes in sleep quality.
- Being less physically active was related to more-negative mood and student status, with those studying full-time seeing a greater reduction in their physical activity.
- Being more physically active was linked to having or suspecting COVID-19 infection within the household. Households where COVID-19 had been experienced or suspected were associated with increasing their physical activity.
- Rural areas in the U.S. have fewer mental health services for young people, shows study
- Researchers examine mental health effects of police violence at the population level
- Study assesses mental health, sleep quality among physically active adults during lockdown
Dr Joanne Ingram added: "This study adds to reports on poor mental health during lockdown and identifies lifestyle restrictions and changes to health behaviours which may be responsible for higher negative mood. Our data suggests that it is advisable to maintain or improve health behaviours during pandemic-associated restrictions, which is important to highlight whilst restrictions are on-going."
Dr Christopher Hand from the Department of Psychology at Glasgow Caledonian University, said: "While we found a relationship between negative change in health behaviours and higher negative mood, our results weren't all doom-and-gloom.
We saw that large numbers of people were able to make healthy changes during lockdown, and these positive changes were associated with better mental health outcomes."